Is Shibuya Sky worth it?
Quick answer
For a first visit to Tokyo, yes — with two conditions. It is worth it if you get a slot near sunset and if the weather lets the rooftop open. On a grey afternoon, from a slot you settled for, it is an expensive look at a large grey city, and several cheaper viewpoints would have done.
The case for it is specific: an open rooftop at 229 metres with no glass in the way, directly above the world's busiest pedestrian crossing. The case against is equally specific: the booking is a chore, the roof shuts in bad weather without a refund, and at 2,700 to 3,400 yen it is dearer than most Tokyo viewpoints.
What you are actually paying for
Open air. Most observation decks in Tokyo put you behind glass, and the photographs show it. Shibuya Sky's SKY STAGE is a rooftop, so the view has nothing between you and the city, and the edge corners look straight down onto Shibuya Crossing. On a clear day the skyline includes Tokyo Tower and Tokyo Skytree, and Mount Fuji is visible when the air is clean, which is more often in winter than in summer.
What people complain about
Three things, consistently. The booking: tickets appear fourteen days out at midnight Japan time and the sunset slots go in minutes. The weather: the rooftop closes for wind, lightning and extreme heat, and neither the ticket nor a tour built around it is refunded when it does. And the lockers: bags and loose items must be stored before you go out, and tripods and selfie sticks are not allowed up at all, which catches out people who came to photograph it.
The cloudy-day question
If the forecast is heavy cloud, consider moving the booking rather than going. The indoor SKY GALLERY on level 46 stays open when the roof closes, so you will see something, but the thing you paid for is the open rooftop. Low cloud does not always mean a bad visit — a city under cloud at dusk can be better than a hazy clear afternoon — but rain with wind usually means the roof is shut.
Who should skip it
Anyone who has one evening and no booked slot, because the scramble is not worth the stress. Anyone travelling with a tight budget, since the free viewpoints around Shibuya cost nothing and give you the district if not the height. And anyone who has already booked Tokyo Skytree: both are observation decks, and doing both on a short trip is a lot of money for a repeated experience, unless the open-air difference is exactly the point for you.
Frequently asked questions
Is Shibuya Sky worth it on a cloudy day?
Less so. The rooftop closes in bad weather and is not refunded, and the indoor gallery is not what you paid for. Cloud alone can still be atmospheric at dusk; rain with wind usually is not.
How much time do you need at Shibuya Sky?
About ninety minutes door to door, including the ascent through SKY GATE and the compulsory locker stop on level 46.
Is it better than Tokyo Skytree?
It is lower and cheaper, and it is open to the air. Skytree is taller, enclosed and unaffected by weather. The comparison page sets them side by side.
Sources